Three Reasons You Should Stop Taking Probiotics

Nutrition Articles

Probiotics are one of the two supplements I used to regularly use with clients. I’ve seen so many people benefit from taking probiotics and that includes myself. So then why did I stop taking probiotics in supplement form?  And why did I recommend to my clients that they stop taking probiotics as well?

There are many good reasons to take probiotics. But here are three considerations to stop taking probiotics!

Well, there used to be one simple reason (see #3 below) to stop taking probiotics but after seeing Sandor Katz speak at a recent conference, I have two additional reasons. 

Reason #1 to Stop Taking Probiotics: Probiotic Supplements Are Proprietary Strains

The first reason is that probiotic supplements are proprietary strains. That means they are formulated in laboratories by companies so they can be patented and then sold for profit. Not that there is anything wrong with that. Many companies put out effective probiotic supplements.

Dozens of studies using probiotic therapy show benefits in treating IBS, constipation, diarrhea, Crohn’s disease, ulcerative colitis, and many other digestive issues.  

However, few studies have ever been done with actual fermented foods. Why?

Because you can’t patent sauerkraut. Or kimchi. Or any food for that matter. 

And let’s not forget that fermented foods are a part of the diet of every traditional culture on this planet.  Fermented vegetables like kimchi, sauerkraut, pickles, as well as fermented dairy like yogurt and cheese, have been around for as long as humans have been around. It is only recently with the advent of refrigeration and processed foods that many industrialized societies have stopped using traditionally fermented foods.

Katz brought up another interesting point regarding probiotic therapy.

Reason #2 to Stop Taking Probiotics: Bacteria are Not Genetically Stable

In the first chapter of his book, The Art of Fermentation, Katz conveys the great mystery of the evolution of bacteria on our planet and the incredible ways in which they communicate, evolve, and transform all life, including human beings. 

“We know more about the stars in the sky than about the soil under our feet,” says microbiologist Elaine Ingham.

Katz depicts bacteria as co-evolvers or even co-creationists in the dance of Life and that they are more influential to our lives and all life on the planet than we can ever realize.  

We have not evolved separately from bacteria. We have evolved together and sure enough, we could not exist without them.

Recent research shows that bacteria freely exchange genetic material. 

This flow of genes allows bacteria to rapidly evolve and adapt to new conditions. It’s the inherent problem with the widespread use of antibiotics in both humans and livestock. Bacteria can adapt quickly and become resistant setting the stage for new diseases and health epidemics.

Katz points out that some microbiologists believe bacteria are not truly distinct species but exist as a continuum across the planet, exchanging and utilizing genes that make them highly adaptable to so many vastly different living conditions. In fact, the human microbiome, that is, the totality of all the microorganisms that reside on and in human beings contains one hundred times more genes than human beings.

A Not-So-Appealing Fact About Your Belly Button

An MIT study also found that the bacteria that reside on and in humans are 25 times more likely to exchange genes than non-human bacteria. Nobody knows why but we know that just as humans are adaptable to almost every climate and landscape on earth, so are bacteria adaptable to all the micro-climates and micro-landscapes of the human body. Armpits, eyebrows, toenails, gums, stomach, and intestines all offer vastly different niches for different strains of bacteria.

In fact, scientists at North Carolina State University found 1400 strains of bacteria that reside just in the human belly button, half of which have never been identified before.

Of course, the majority of the human microbiome resides in our gut and the research on these intestinal bacteria is nothing short of mind-blowing, literally speaking. In addition to playing vital roles in our physical health, it turns out they may be able to influence our mental health as well. 

Before I get too far out on a tangent, what that means for us is that specific strains of bacteria may not be as important as once thought. In other words, probiotic therapy is based on the belief that certain strains are vital for our health. And so we take these capsules with billions of strains of Lactobacillus and/or Bifidobacteria and maybe a few others. Every company has a different formulation of different strains with different studies and reasons why their formulation is best.

However, the genetic fluidity of bacteria suggests that variety and diversity may be more beneficial than specific strains.

This is certainly what Katz believes.

And it makes sense to me as well. After all, if there are hundreds of newly identified bacteria in our belly buttons, who knows how many have yet to be discovered in fermented foods? 

So while a probiotic supplement may offer help, over the long term I think it’s more important to regularly incorporate Nature’s true probiotics, fermented foods.

Reason #3 to Stop Taking Probiotics: Your Digestive Issue is in the Past

This is why I stopped taking probiotics and this is when I tell my clients to stop taking probiotics.  Nevertheless, many people continue to take pricey probiotic supplements for preventative reasons. 

While I think that’s safer than taking drugs like statins for preventative reasons, remember, fermented foods give us a far greater variety and complexity of beneficial bacteria than probiotic supplements.  While we can’t deny the benefits of probiotic supplementation, over the long term I trust the thousands of years of fermented foods in the human diet more than laboratory formulations.  

Give me fermented foods over supplements any day.

Much tastier too.

Learn to Make Fermented Vegetables at Home

While you certainly can find good sources of fermented foods in your local health food store,  it’s a lot more rewarding (and cost-efficient) to make them at home.

All my clients learn about the health benefits of fermented foods. Want to learn?  It’s so easy! Pick up a copy of Wild Fermentation or Katz’s new more expansive book on the subject, The Art of Fermentation.

Or check out some of my simple fermentation recipes here:

More Nutrition Articles from Fearless Eating

There are many good reasons to take probiotics. But here are three considerations to stop taking probiotics!
Fearless Eating may receive commissions from purchases made through links in this article. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. More info here.
Three Reasons You Should Stop Taking Probiotics

About the Author

Craig Fear is the creator of Fearless Eating and the author of three books, The 30-Day Heartburn Solution, Fearless Broths and Soups and The Thai Soup Secret. After years helping clients with digestive issues, Craig decided to pursue writing full-time. He intends to write many more books on broths and soups from around the world! Click here to learn more about Craig.

(158) comments

Add Your Reply