Gelatinous Bone Broth: Stock Pot or Crock Pot?

Bone Broths

Which is better for making a gelatinous bone broth - a stock pot or a crock pot? Here's the answer with video proof.

Fearless Eating may receive commissions from purchases made through links in this article. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. More info here.

©Depositphotos.com/jianghongyan
©Depositphotos.com/brittny_ann

One of the tell-tale signs of a properly made homemade bone broth (also called bone stock) is how well it gels upon cooling.

This gelling is a result of the gelatin that leaches out of the collagen in animal products.  Gelatin is what makes Jello giggle and it should do the same for your homemade broths.

But it’s not always a given that you’ll get a gelatinous bone broth when making a bone broth.

I learned this valuable lesson last week when I went a little bone broth crazy.

My little chest freezer was filling up with beef bones fast and I needed to make some bone broth to clear up some space.

So I did.  As you can see, I made about 12 quarts of beef broth.

Which is better for making a gelatinous bone broth - a stock pot or a crock pot? Here's the answer with video proof.

I made them all at the same time which meant that I had to use both my crock pot (also called a slow cooker) and a stock pot.

Now I’m glad I did this because I was able to get a good comparison of the difference between making broths in a crock pot versus a stock pot.

I made sure that I had the exact same ingredients in both the crock pot and the stock pot.

The Verdict

Here’s a quick video showing the gelatinous difference in the outcome:

Yes, I’ll be using stock pots a lot more in the future!

Controlling the temperature is one of the key ways to get a more gelatinous bone broth.   And you can’t do that with most crock pots.

Now if you know of a brand where you can set the EXACT temperature, please share in the comments below.  I’d love to know.

Additional Tips to Make a Gelatinous Bone Broth

Controlling the temperature is just one factor in getting a nice gelatinous bone broth.

Other keys to a gelatinous broth are using a variety of bones and using the correct ratio of bones to water.

Sarah Pope over at The Healthy Home Economist has a nice blog that details 5 reasons why your stock won’t gel.

And my recent guest post on The Coconut Mama includes a recipe for how to make a gelatinous bone broth.

Get a Good Stock Pot!

If you’re in the market for a new stock pot I’d recommend one that has deep, straight sides and is at least 12 quarts.

Because I’m making so much stock these days I just got this this 20 quart stock pot on Amazon.

Which is better for making a gelatinous bone broth - a stock pot or a crock pot? Here's the answer with video proof.

I love that I can now make double, if not triple the amount of stock that I used to at one time.  It’s very reasonably priced and it’s certified by the National Sanitation Foundation (NSF).  NSF is an independent third-party that has strict standards for the safe design of kitchen tools and appliances (among many other things).  

You can get a smaller or larger stock pot  based on your individual needs.

These days, I just can’t get enough bone broth.   I’m using it more and more in my everyday cooking, not just for a huge variety of soups but also for things like sauces, gravies, cooking rice, vegetables and even just having a small cup before bedtime.  I even give some to the dog with her food and when I do, boy does she light up!

The list of uses for bone broths continues to grow.

Any tips for making a gelatinous bone broth that you’d like to add?   I’m always learning and love to hear from others. Please share in the comments!

Which is better for making a gelatinous bone broth - a stock pot or a crock pot? Here's the answer with video proof.

Follow

About the Author

Craig Fear is the creator of Fearless Eating and the author of three books, The 30-Day Heartburn Solution, Fearless Broths and Soups and The Thai Soup Secret. After years helping clients with digestive issues, Craig decided to pursue writing full-time. He intends to write many more books on broths and soups from around the world! Click here to learn more about Craig.

(42) comments

Add Your Reply
close

Learn to STOP Acid Reflux! 

And learn how an ancient, simple food is a much healthier and safer option to drugs!

  • The little-known root cause to heartburn that the pharmaceutical industry doesn’t want you to know.
  • Why popular OTC drugs cause long-term health problems such as bone loss and nutrient deficiencies.
  • check
    12 heartburn-busting recipes to get started!
Pin488
Share49
Share
Pocket
Yum